Car dragged by police while stuck in third gear - damage?

Boxster and Cayman discussion area

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
Neo
Posts: 13
Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2011 9:54 am
Location: London
Contact:

Car dragged by police while stuck in third gear - damage?

Post by Neo »

Hi Everyone,

I bought my Porsche Cayman S two weeks ago, and on Friday it broke down. The gear stick went floppy and it was stuck in third gear. Looks like the gear linkage has failed.

However, I had broken down in a dangerous position on Park Lane, Mayfair in London and the police attended and said that they had to drag my car off the road "in the interests of public safety". One of the police officers sat in my driver's seat while another officer towed the car off the road. I'm not sure if the officer in my car depressed the clutch while it was dragged, but judging from what they were saying about safety being more important than damage to the car, I suspect he may not have done.

If this was the case, it means that the car was pulled about 25 yards in third gear, the wheels rolled freely, so the engine would have been turned over while not running. The car had last been running about 45 minutes earlier.

I'm worried that this may have damaged the engine given that oil was not flowing through the engine, but the pulling force will effectively have been doing what fuel ignition normally does. Is it possible the engine could've been damaged, or do I have nothing to worry about at all?
In the end, there can be only one.
grbspeedster
Posts: 277
Joined: Tue Nov 06, 2007 5:21 pm
TIPEC membership: 0
Location: Nr Rugby

Re: Car dragged by police while stuck in third gear - damage

Post by grbspeedster »

I am sure they would have put clutch down, you would have seen back of car dip with load from engine if they hadnt, and sound of engine spinning over.Oil pump is mechanical drive so oil would have been circulated if engine spining
Geoff
1989 911 Speedster
2014 Jaguar XFS
Neo
Posts: 13
Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2011 9:54 am
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Car dragged by police while stuck in third gear - damage

Post by Neo »

Well, I hope so (that he put the clutch down). The reason I suspect it might not have done is because I was expressing a lot of concern about dragging it off in gear and about potentially damaging the engine, and he said that is of no concern where there is a safety issue - he didn't mention about dipping the clutch at all during this exchange. It was only after the police left that I realised about doing this, hence why I didn't think to ask him if he did.

Good to know it won't have done any damage thought - the Porsche garage where it's at now said the same.
In the end, there can be only one.
murky
Posts: 1
Joined: Wed Apr 10, 2013 8:52 am
TIPEC membership: 2

Re: Car dragged by police while stuck in third gear - damage

Post by murky »

grbspeedster wrote:I am sure they would have put clutch down, you would have seen back of car dip with load from engine if they hadnt, and sound of engine spinning over.Oil pump is mechanical drive so oil would have been circulated if engine spining
YES! i think your right!good advice
The weapon of the advocate is the sword of the soldier, not the lock pick of the assassin.
Post Reply